How AI is reshaping Professional Indemnity Insurance in the UK
The implementation of artificial intelligence (AI) continues to dominate discussions across every industry. In the context of Professional Indemnity Insurance (PII), AI is transforming efficiency, risk management and claims handling, while introducing challenges around cybersecurity and liability.
For UK businesses, AI can streamline operations and reduce labour costs. However, with generative AI only becoming mainstream in 2023, its coexistence with human decision-making remains immature. This can pose risks to both the policyholder and insurer. In this guide, we explore how AI is influencing the PII landscape, what advantages and risks this brings, and how firms can secure the right policy with appropriate protection.
How is AI affecting the Professional Indemnity Insurance industry?
AI-generated content is now embedded across everything from social media to virtual assistants. It improves productivity for consumers and allows businesses to generate marketing content, reports and customer communications in minutes. The insurance sector is no exception. AI is being used to assess risk, process claims, manage underwriting and support customer engagement.
For professional firms seeking Professional Indemnity Insurance, AI also introduces new contractual considerations. Policies may need to include clauses covering how AI-driven errors or omissions are handled, particularly where liability is unclear.
However, AI’s emerging status brings uncertainty. If an AI tool generates incorrect advice resulting in a loss, insurers may dispute the claim, arguing that the liability falls outside the scope of cover. Leading AI companies such as OpenAI include limitation of liability clauses in their licensing agreements, often shifting responsibility to the business user, not the AI provider.
The advantages of AI in the PII industry
Despite its risks, AI also offers several clear benefits to insurance providers and policyholders:
-
Improved cybersecurity detection – AI can spot anomalies and threats in real time
-
Reduced costs – Lower overheads compared with human labour
-
Increased operational efficiency – Automates time-consuming tasks
-
Zero downtime – AI can operate continuously without breaks
-
Evolving intelligence – Machine learning models improve over time
-
Competitive edge – Insurers using AI can offer tailored, data-led protection
When supported by human oversight, AI can become an asset to insurers and clients alike.
The risks of AI in Professional Indemnity Insurance
The downside of AI becomes clear when businesses use it without proper supervision. Below are two prominent examples that highlight this issue:
Tyndaris SAM v MMWWVWM Ltd (UK, 2019)
A London-based investment firm developed a trading platform using AI. Promoted as more effective than traditional managers, the platform operated independently and caused severe financial losses. Legal action followed, raising key questions about AI accountability.
Morgan & Morgan case (USA, 2023)
In a dispute involving Walmart, a lawyer used AI to draft court filings. The citations provided were entirely fictitious. The platform had ‘hallucinated’ the sources, which were submitted unchecked. The result: court sanctions and professional fines.
These incidents demonstrate why human review is essential. Errors can lead to invalidated PII claims or cause insurers to reject cover on the basis of procedural failure.
Summary of key risks:
-
AI can ‘hallucinate’ and produce false or inaccurate content
-
Ethical oversight and professional judgement remain critical
-
Lack of transparency in AI decision-making may complicate claim outcomes
Does my PII policy cover AI-generated content or services?
If your business uses AI at any stage – from report generation to client communications – you should review your current Professional Indemnity Insurance policy to ensure it reflects these risks.
In a recent spotlight by RSA Insurance, Ed Ambrose, Head of Professional Indemnity, said:
“The rise of generative AI is highly relevant to all professions covered by PI insurance, as Gen AI spreads and becomes business-as-usual. We are likely assuming, but not yet pricing for, Gen AI exposures in our PI book. Silent AI, as it were, akin to the ‘Silent Cyber’ that came before.”
He added:
“Our PI book is exposed to future claims with the current difference being limited stand-alone AI cover products. Professions such as accountancy and law appear to be leading in AI adoption. Although we have not yet experienced claims, we are now introducing questions on existing and new risks regarding AI usage and the controls in place.”
In short, if your firm uses AI in any meaningful capacity, it is essential to declare this to your insurer and ensure your cover is both comprehensive and future-proof.
Secure your Professional Indemnity Insurance with a business loan
We help hundreds of firms each year across the legal, accountancy and conveyancing sectors to finance their Professional Indemnity Insurance through tailored business loans. For those introducing automation or AI, premiums may need to reflect enhanced risk or include specialist cover.
Explore:
-
Case studies showing how clients have protected their practices
If you use AI or are considering it, make sure your insurance policy is aligned. We can help you spread the cost and stay protected.
Talk to us
If you are looking to find the right finance for your business, contact us today.
Discover the right business products all in one place.
Tell us about your business.
